A Monster's Expedition Review: Against My Will, I Found Joy (Sometimes)
Dear Draknek & Friends, I came here to scoff at your tree-pushing antics, but then something strange happened. I actually, grudgingly, enjoyed myself. Don't let it go to your heads.
An Open Letter to Draknek & Friends, Regarding My Precious Time
Dear Draknek & Friends, I need to talk to you about your game. Another one. You know, A Monster's Expedition, the one with the trees. When I first heard it was an 'open-world puzzle game about pushing trees,' my eyes rolled so hard I think I saw last Tuesday. 'Relaxing,' they said. 'Adorable,' they said. I am Paul, not some yoga guru looking for digital zen. I play games to be challenged, or at least for the developers to earn my disdain. After the mind-bending, existential crises your team delivered with Baba Is You, I approached this with a healthy dose of suspicion. And yes, a healthy dose of pure, unadulterated grumpiness. I expected some simplistic mobile garbage, but then you had to go and make me rethink my entire afternoon.
The Unexpected Mechanics of Logging and Loathing
So, you push trees. Big deal, right? Sokoban has been doing block pushing since before most of you were even a twinkle in your parents' eyes. But no, you had to make it different. These trees become bridges, platforms, solutions. The genius, and I use that word begrudgingly, is how every single tree you move changes the landscape, opening some paths while closing others. It is not just about clearing a single screen, it is about understanding the flow of an entire archipelago. I found myself staring at a small island for minutes, trying to visualize a multi-step sequence, something I usually reserve for, well, better games. Then there are the 'artifacts' you are supposed to inspect, which I assume are just excuses to make me push more trees. Humanity's culture, sure, I will get right on that after I finish this damn log puzzle.
My Eyes, They Witnessed... Competence
Let us talk about the visuals and audio, because someone has to. I braced myself for the usual indie pixel art mess or some generic unity assets. Instead, I got, gasp, a cohesive and rather pleasant aesthetic. The art style is clean, functional, and yes, I will admit, kind of charming in its simplicity. The monsters are blobby and unintrusive. The islands look like little dioramas. The music, surprisingly, did not drive me insane. It is calm, atmospheric, and manages to avoid being either aggressively cheerful or annoyingly repetitive. This is a high bar for me, considering most game soundtracks these days sound like they were composed by an AI having a bad day. It certainly does not break any ground, but it absolutely supports the puzzling experience without getting in the way.
A Moment of Weakness, Where My Guard Slipped
Here is the rub, the part where I have to admit you did something right. The 'open world' aspect, which I initially scoffed at, is not a gimmick. It is brilliant. If I got stuck on one island's conundrum, I could just sail my little tree raft to another. This means less frustrating restarts, less rage-quitting, and more consistent engagement. This interconnectedness, where solving a puzzle on one island creates a path to a completely different one, is where the real cleverness lies. It is not just about individual puzzles, but a sprawling, interconnected network of environmental logic. I found myself thinking, 'Oh, I can use that tree from *there* to get *here*!' It is a genuinely satisfying loop that few puzzle games manage to achieve. Draknek, you manipulative geniuses, you got me.
The Persistent Nagging of Unsolved Problems, a Familiar Anguish
Why did I keep playing? The short answer is the game would not let me go. Every time I thought I was done, another tantalizingly close island would appear on the horizon, daring me to navigate its timber-based challenges. It is that 'just one more puzzle' itch that most good puzzle games scratch, but here, it is amplified by the freedom of choice. This is not some linear gauntlet where you hit a wall and are forced to bang your head against it until it breaks. The game respects my impatience, allowing me to wander off and find another puzzle to be irritated by. So yes, I played for far longer than I intended. And yes, my brain feels like a wrung-out sponge, but at least it feels like it actually got a workout, not just a repetitive strain injury.
Rating Breakdown
It just, works, which is more than I can say for most games released these days.
Pushing trees is old news, but the environmental interactions actually feel fresh and interconnected.
For nineteen bucks, you are getting a lot of head-scratching, which I suppose is a kind of value.
I hated that I loved it, the puzzles really did pull me in despite myself.
The 'adorable' aesthetic is fine, I guess, and the music did not make me want to rip my ears off, a rare feat.
Once you have solved a puzzle, it is solved, unless you are some kind of speedrunner, which I am not.
What Didn't Annoy Me
- Alright, fine, the puzzles are genuinely smart, I will admit it.
- The way the islands link together is actually quite brilliant, no endless linearity.
- It is surprisingly forgiving, letting you wander off if you get stuck.
- The aesthetic is not actively offensive, which is a low bar but still.
- The artifacts, I suppose, add a touch of charming absurdity.
What Made Me Sigh
- Draknek, why must you make my brain hurt so much?
- The price feels a bit steep for a game about pushing logs, does not it?
- Sometimes the 'open world' just means I get lost looking for the next puzzle, developers, that is not fun.
- The 'adorable' vibe occasionally felt a bit too saccharine for my grumpy tastes.
What I will remember about A Monster's Expedition in six months is the infuriating satisfaction of finally clearing a path through a dense cluster of trees, and the faint feeling of 'wait, that was actually good.' This game is a sneaky one. It presents itself as a simple, relaxing tree-pusher, then subtly forces you to engage parts of your brain you thought long atrophied. It is not a Baba Is You, not that kind of revolutionary, but it is a very clever evolution of environmental puzzles. I rolled my eyes, then I got hooked. If you are tired of games demanding your twitch reflexes and endless grind, and you do not mind a good head-scratcher, you might, might, just find yourself enjoying this one, despite yourself. Do not tell anyone I said that.
Played this game? Share your score.
You rated this /10
More Like This
Patrick's Parabox: A Puzzle Game So Clever It Almost Made Me Smile
Dear Patrick Traynor, your game is a clever little torment. It's the kind of puzzle that makes me wish I was still 12 and had unlimited brain cells to burn, but even then, it would have been a headache.
The Case of the Golden Idol: Alright, You Win. This One's Actually Good.
Look, I hate admitting it, but Color Gray Games actually made something worth playing. Yes, *I* said it. Get over it.
Family Review: Is This Musical Genealogy Puzzle Worth Your Time, Or Just a History Lesson?
Another day, another indie puzzle game begging for my attention. 'Family' promises detective work in musical genealogy, which sounds either brilliant or like homework. Guess which way I'm leaning?
Silver Thread: Deux Review â An RPG Maker Puzzle Game That Almost Made Me Care About Ghosts
Dear Spicaze, I've played approximately 47,000 RPG Maker horror-puzzle games in my lifetime, and yours managed to keep me awake through the entire 90-minute runtime. That's either a compliment to you or an indictment of my life choices.