Loading ...
PUZZLE
Runic Review: A Free Puzzle Game That Actually Remembers What 'Short and Sweet' Means
I've played approximately 847 'atmospheric puzzle games' this month, and most of them mistake 'ambient soundtrack' for 'having a personality.' Runic doesn't reinvent anything, but at least it knows what it is and doesn't waste my time pretending otherwise.
Paul
January 21, 2026
5.8
Overall Score
"Runic is the gaming equivalent of a competent but unremarkable short story â it does what it sets out to do without embarrassing itself, but it won't stick with you past tomorrow."
First Impressions (Or: My Expectations Were in the Basement)
Look, when I see 'atmospheric puzzle game' and 'rune placement' in the same sentence, my brain immediately defaults to 'oh great, another wannabe indie darling that thinks vague mysticism equals depth.' I loaded up Runic fully prepared to write my standard 'this needed six more months in development' rant. But here's the thing â it didn't immediately crash, the UI actually responded to my clicks, and within thirty seconds I was solving puzzles instead of fighting with the controls. That's... actually kind of refreshing? The premise is pure fantasy boilerplate: lone soul, evil forest, restore the runes, save the day. I've seen this setup in literally dozens of games, but at least Runic has the decency to get straight to the point instead of drowning me in fifteen minutes of exposition about ancient prophecies I don't care about.
The Rune Placement System (Where Things Get Mildly Interesting)
The core mechanic is exactly what it says on the tin: you wander through a top-down forest finding runes and placing them on altars to solve puzzles. It's not revolutionary â games have been doing 'find object, place object' puzzles since the 1980s â but the execution is competent enough that I didn't want to quit after five minutes. The puzzles themselves range from 'oh, that's clever' to 'yeah, I've done this exact puzzle in six other games.' What bothers me is that the difficulty never really escalates. I kept waiting for that moment where the game would throw a genuinely challenging puzzle at me, something that would make me pause and actually think, but it never happened. Every altar felt more or less the same level of challenge, which means the gameplay loop gets repetitive fast. I wanted spatial reasoning challenges, pattern recognition tests, SOMETHING that would make my brain actually engage. Instead, I got a pleasant but ultimately forgettable sequence of simple tasks.
Visuals and Audio (Finally, Someone Who Understands 'Cohesive Art Direction')
I'll give credit where it's due: the sprite work here is genuinely nice. Agnes Kinnander and Line._.Life clearly understood the assignment â the forest actually looks like a place I'd want to explore, the runes have distinct visual identities, and there's a consistent aesthetic that ties everything together. Too many indie games slap together mismatched asset packs and call it a day, but Runic has a unified look that shows actual artistic vision. The sound design by Eric Wrethagen is similarly competent. The ambient forest sounds don't grate on my nerves, and the music creates atmosphere without being obnoxiously present. It's not going to win any awards, but it doesn't need to â it does its job and gets out of the way. My only complaint is that everything feels a bit TOO safe. Give me some visual flourish, some audio surprise, something that makes me go 'oh, THAT'S unexpected.' But for a free game made by a small team, the production values are legitimately solid.
Exploration and Pacing (Short Doesn't Have to Mean Shallow)
Here's where Runic actually gets something right that most puzzle games completely fumble: it respects my time. The game is short â I finished it in about forty minutes â and it knows it's short. There's no padding, no pointless backtracking, no artificial lengthening through tedious fetch quests. You explore the forest, find the runes, solve the puzzles, face the evil, done. In 2025, when every indie dev thinks their game needs to be a fifteen-hour epic, having something that says 'here's a compact experience, enjoy it and move on' is actually kind of bold. My issue is that the exploration itself is fairly linear. The top-down forest looks nice, but there's not much reason to deviate from the main path. I wanted hidden areas, optional challenges, SOMETHING to reward curiosity. Instead, it's a straight shot from start to finish with minimal deviation. That's fine for what it is, but it means there's zero discovery beyond the main objectives.
What This Game Actually Needs (Besides a Difficulty Curve)
The foundation here is solid enough that with more development time, Runic could have been genuinely memorable instead of just 'pleasant.' What it desperately needs is puzzle variety and escalating complexity. Give me spatial manipulation challenges. Make me think about rune combinations. Introduce mechanics that build on each other. The game introduces rune placement and then just... does that same thing for the entire runtime. I also wanted more environmental storytelling. The forest is atmospheric, sure, but it's also kind of empty narratively. Show me the history of these runes through visual cues. Let me piece together what happened here through environmental details. Give me a REASON to care about restoring these altars beyond 'the game told me to.' And please, PLEASE add some optional content for players who want more than a forty-minute experience. Secret puzzles, hidden runes, alternate solutions â something that rewards thorough exploration.
The Reality Check (When 'Free' Isn't an Excuse)
I know what you're thinking: 'Paul, it's a FREE game made by a small team, cut them some slack.' And look, I'm not expecting AAA polish here. But being free doesn't mean a game gets a pass on basic design principles. Runic is competent and pleasant, which puts it ahead of most free itch.io games, but it's also completely forgettable. I finished it, thought 'that was fine,' and immediately moved on with my life. There's no hook that makes this stand out from the hundreds of other atmospheric puzzle games. The rune placement system isn't unique enough to carry the experience. The puzzles aren't challenging enough to satisfy puzzle enthusiasts. The exploration isn't deep enough to appeal to adventure game fans. It's caught in this middle ground where it does everything adequately but nothing exceptionally. That said, for a free forty-minute experience, you could do FAR worse. If you've got an evening to kill and want something mildly engaging that won't frustrate you, Runic fits that bill perfectly.
Rating Breakdown
Quality
6.2
For a free Unity project, it's surprisingly functional â no game-breaking bugs crashed my session, which automatically puts it above half the stuff I reviewed yesterday.
Innovation
4.8
Rune placement puzzles in a fantasy forest, how delightfully original â I definitely haven't seen this exact premise since, oh, last Tuesday.
Value
7.5
It's free and short, which means I didn't lose money OR three hours of my life I'll never get back, so honestly, that's a win in my book.
Gameplay
5.9
The puzzle loop is fine â place runes, solve altar puzzles, move on â but I kept waiting for that moment where it would surprise me, and it never came.
Audio/Visual
6.8
The sprites have actual personality and the music doesn't make me want to rip my headphones off, which is genuinely more than I expected from a free itch.io game.
Replayability
3.5
Once you've placed all the runes and saved the forest, there's absolutely zero reason to ever boot this up again â it's a one-evening affair, period.
What Didn't Annoy Me
Actually functional on launch, which apparently makes it a unicorn among Unity puzzle games
Cohesive art direction with sprites that show genuine artistic effort instead of lazy asset flips
Mercifully short runtime that doesn't overstay its welcome or pad itself with artificial lengthening
Free price tag means the barrier to entry is literally just your time, and it won't waste much of it
Sound design that creates atmosphere without being obnoxiously present or grating after five minutes
What Made Me Sigh
Puzzle difficulty flatlines immediately and never escalates beyond 'mildly engaging'
Rune placement mechanic brings absolutely nothing new to a genre that's been doing this since the '90s
Zero replayability â once you've saved the forest, there's no reason to ever launch this again
Exploration is too linear with no hidden secrets or rewards for curiosity
Final Verdict
Runic is the gaming equivalent of a competent but unremarkable short story â it does what it sets out to do without embarrassing itself, but it won't stick with you past tomorrow. For a free forty-minute puzzle game, it's perfectly adequate: the sprites are nice, the puzzles function, and it doesn't crash. But adequate isn't memorable. The rune placement system needed more depth, the puzzles needed actual challenge progression, and the exploration needed reasons to exist beyond 'walk to the next altar.' If you've got an evening to spare and want something mildly atmospheric that won't demand much from you, Runic fits that niche. Just don't expect it to revolutionize your understanding of puzzle games or even leave a lasting impression. It's fine. And sometimes, especially when it's free, 'fine' is honestly good enough.
Runic
Tags
puzzle
rune-placement
fantasy
top-down
short-game
atmospheric
casual
free
Are you a developer and want to remove this review?